|
Even though there are some very good entries from time-to-time, I'd avoid this book to save yourself from possibly adopting this type of relationship with God. Because he failed to ask this question is the reason why God let him be injured.In the same light, if things go right, this type of approaches gives the wrong impression that is must be because I was so good in hearing God and doing exactly what he told me.Even stranger, he uses Romans 4 to claim that he heard his dead dog bark from heaven.
As the book progresses, John becomes more and more bent on asking God everything: Should he adopt a puppy, should he stay late for work, should he chop down a Christmas tree on Friday. he even asks God where his watch is.To me, this type of highly introspective faith is very dangerous.
Very disappointed with this book. He reasons he asked him if he should ride a horse, but that he didn't ask WHERE he should go.
If something goes wrong, it must be our fault for not listening to God. John gets thrown off a horse at one point, and the first thing he does is try to evaluate where he went wrong with God.
I do know that scripture says the only way to heaven is through Jesus Christ, and I do not know of any dogs who've personally accepted Christ.Very strange. This book really turned me off from John Edlredge.
This is a must read for men seeking to improve their relationship with the creator of heaven and earth. John places his life experiences in a biblical context and demonstrates how we can grow as men and as Christians. This book has changed my life and I thought I was pretty cool. I wasn't.
I am leading an adult Christian education class whose members are reading the book and discussing sections of it each week over a 10 week time period. The author presents an easy to read journal of his thoughts about what he encounters in life over the course of a year. Members of the class are also keeping a journal of their thoughts and their adventures in listening to God. He writes of listening to God for answers for some of the things that concern him. At times, he is very thought provoking and at others mundane. I recommend this book to anyone who is serious about his faith journey. JoAnn Van Tassel
John's book is a collection of stories from his own prayer journey, put together with some step-by-step instructions and how to start one's own journey toward conversational intimacy with God. He lays out a logical case for being able to hear from God, supported by scripture. There were a couple of things he proposes and/or practices that have challenged my own theology and practices, which I continue to wrestle with in a good way.
Like I said, it made me think differently.The one problem that I see in this book is that Eldredge makes everything a battle. Should I walk across the street or not. John Eldredge really puts himself out there for this book, admitting his struggles, internal battles, and sharing his year-long walk with God. Lewis once wrote, "There are two equal and opposite errors into which our race can fall about the devils.
I have never really assumed that God cares so deeply about the mundane details of my - or any - life. It takes courage to put oneself out there, to show one's imperfections and thoughts to thousands of readers. And making everything a battle is somewhat unhealthy. It is an interesting read. But, according to Eldredge, God not only cares about the mundane details of our lives, he wants us to include him in everything.
C.S. Unique, for sure. First, this book made me think differently about what it means to walk with God. One is to disbelieve in their existence. He writes, ".hearing God requires surrender, giving all things over into his hands." And Eldredge means everything.
Everything from picking out a new puppy to going on a horse ride. The other is to believe, and to feel an excessive and unhealthy interest in them." Eldredge borders and tiptoes around the latter. I recommend it.
|
